5 Stars - Based on
(3 Reviews)

Are you planning to purchase a smoker?! Then, you must be feeling confused between electric vs propane smoker! Meat smoking enthusiasts seem divided between the two types. While many admire the modern-age electric smokers, others prefer the propane versions. To save you from this confusion, this guide has collected some of the best electric as well as propane smokers. These reviews will help you choose a smoker that exactly matches your needs. Plus, you will gain some valuable tips to further understand the right way of buying a smoker. So, let’s find out!

Comparing Electric Vs Propane Smokers



Char-Broil 19202101 electric smokerMasterbuilt 20071117 electric smokerMasterbuilt 20078715 electric smokerSmoke PS4415 propane smokerMasterbuilt 20051311 GS30D Propane Smoker
Product NameChar-Broil 19202101 Digital Electric SmokerMasterbuilt 30" Digital Electric SmokerMasterbuilt Electric Digital SmokerSmoke Hollow PS4415 Propane SmokerMasterbuilt 20051311 2-Door Propane Smoker

725 Sq. Inch

720 Sq. Inch

721 Sq. Inch

Large Capacity

717 Sq. Inch







Item Dimensions

32.5 x 18.1 x 16.5 in

19.88 x 20.47 x 33.27 in

19.68 x 16.93 x 32.13 in

24.47 x 33.29 x 60.83 in

21.1 x 21.4 x 43.5 in

Item Weight

58.8 pounds

39.34 lbs

50.04 lbs

93 lbs

58.43 lbs

Power Source







Here is a list of electric vs. propane smoker reviews you can follow to make a selection:


Char-Broil 19202101 Deluxe Black Digital Electric Smoker

This is an ideal electric smoker if you want to indulge in outdoor cooking, smoking or grilling. It enables you to cook a wide range of meats due to a vast internal space of 725 sq.in. The smokebox also has an optimal capacity to provide smoke for 4-7 hours without needing a refill. So, you can r